COMM 337: Robert Fisk interviews Osama bin Laden

On Wednesday I'll have an assignment sheet for your first analytical paper, on a piece of public affairs reporting by British correspondent Robert Fisk. In the meantime, here's a link to the piece I want you to read ... it's a chapter from his book The Great War for Civilisation: the Conquest of the Middle East. In it he tells about the three times he has interviewed Osama bin Laden.

(The "s" in the title is CQ. Fisk is British, and he uses British spellings.)

Fisk writes for The Independent, a center-left newspaper in London. He has lived in the Middle East since the 1980s, and he is a fierce critic of U.S. and British foreign policy in the region. He is no less critical of Israel, and he has been accused of anti-Semitism. I don't think those charges have been proven, at least not by my definition of anti-Semitism, but you should be aware of the controversy over his writing.

In a perceptive review of The Great War in The New York Times, English author Geoffrey Wheatcroft says Fisk "is one of the most controversial journalists of the age, winner of numerous prizes, much admired by some, including colleagues who respect his obsessive attention to detail and sheer physical courage, execrated by others because of what has been seen as his open hostility to Israel, America and the West." Wheatcroft says the book is much too long, and Fisk's "ungovernable anger may do his heart credit, but it does not make for satisfactory history." But when Fisk sticks to straight reporting, Wheatcroft says, The Great War is "a stimulating and absorbing book, by a man who speaks Arabic, who has known the region better than most and has met the leading players, from bin Laden to Ahmad Chalabi (who offered to introduce him to Oliver North)." Fisk has reported, quite literally, on one war after the other since he was first posted to the Middle East in 1982.

"This is really several books fighting each other inside the sack," says Wheatcroft.

Another reviewer, a former British ambassador Libya, Luxembourg and Greece named Oliver Miles, agrees Fisk's book is "excessively long ... a real War and Peace, but with precious little peace." (We're reading about 25 pages out of 1,283.) In his review in The Guardian (U.K.), Miles says, "Vigilant editing and ruthless pruning could perhaps have made two or three good short books out of this one." But when Fisk isn't venting his opinion, his reporting is masterful. Says Miles, "His forte is straight reporting, such as his three interviews with Osama bin Laden."