Assessment: High-stakes test quote of the day

From The Independent, a center-left newspaper in London, the quote of the day -- perhaps the quote of the year -- on high-stakes testing. It comes in a story about new secondary school testing standards announced by the Labour government, raising mandated proficiency levels on the GCSE tests taken by 11-year-olds nationwide. Said Jovan Trkulga, a supply (substitute) teacher at Deptford Green primary in Lewisham, south London:

"High-stakes testing has got to a ridiculous state... it is making children unhappy. Telling teachers they have to improve their children's performance is like teaching your grandmother to suck eggs."

British GCSE tests measure students' mastery of the national General Certificate of Secondary Education curriculum. The government, which is more directly involved in curriculum than the U.S. government, today announced tighter new standards in math and English:

The new targets will mean ministers expect 53 per cent off youngsters to obtain five A* to C grade passes at GCSE – including maths and English – by the end of the decade. At present, only 45 per cent do – although this figure has risen from 35 per cent in 1997.

In addition, ministers have repeated their target of getting 85 per cent of youngsters to reach the required standard in national curriculum test for 11-year-olds by the end of the decade. Previously, this target had been set for 2006 but it would need a five percentage point rise in English and nine percentage point rise in maths to achieve the target.

Sounds a little bit like No Child Left Behind in the U.S., doesn't it? So does the reaction:

Teachers' leaders breathed a sigh of relief after it emerged ministers planned a bigger increase in education spending than had previously been forecast. However, they warned that the targets could lead to more "teaching to the tests", with the danger that more pupils could be put off learning.